Official National Beta Sponsor  

  • Custom trading pin in the shape of Illinois featuring a fierce red and black hawk gripping a baseball bat, with “McHenry Hawks Baseball” in bold text. Surrounding the design are numbered baseballs from 00 to 11, representing team player numbers.
  • Custom trading pin for the Blue Angels softball team, featuring a yellow softball with silver wings, two crossed bats, and a glittery blue background. Yellow softballs with blue numbers encircle the design, displaying team player numbers like 00, 9, 14, and 22.
  • Custom trading pin shaped like a black and orange baseball jersey featuring “Giants Georgia” across the chest. A white banner at the bottom reads “9U USSSA World Series 2015,” marking the event and team division.
  • Custom trading pin for the Marlboro Pirates baseball team, featuring a pirate flag with a skull and crossbones, a partial baseball in the background, and a pile of gold coins marked with player numbers. The team name is displayed in bold yellow and white lettering with a red sword detail.
  • Custom trading pin for the Texas Express baseball team featuring a black steam train emerging from clouds of smoke, set against a green and black star. The word “Express” appears in large glittery green lettering with a white baseball bat underneath and the year 2015 on the handle.
  • Custom trading pin for the Desert Knights baseball team featuring a silver knight in full armor with a flowing purple cape, holding a sword and shield. The background includes a stitched baseball and diamond frame, with bold purple and silver text reading “Desert Knights.”

Baseball Trading Pins

Get ready to knock it out of the park and turn heads like never before! Our Baseball Trading Pins aren't just pins; they're a ticket to unforgettable experiences and lasting memories. Whether you're headed to Cooperstown's legendary fields or taking part in Little League Baseball, our pins are your ultimate game-changer. Built to last and designed to impress, these pins will elevate your team's camaraderie, spark conversations, and leave a lasting impression long after the final inning. Step up your trading game and be the envy of every tournament with our unmatched quality and style.

Soft Enamel Trading Pin
Size 100 200 300 500 750 1000 2000
1.25" $3.17 $2.62 $1.83 $1.27 $1.14 $1.01 $0.99
1.5" $3.40 $2.85 $2.05 $1.54 $1.46 $1.25 $1.15
1.75" $3.58 $3.20 $2.50 $1.90 $1.83 $1.54 $1.36
2" $4.02 $3.35 $2.77 $2.17 $2.01 $1.78 $1.68
2.25" $5.64 $4.24 $3.58 $2.81 $2.60 $2.52 $2.23
2.5" $6.40 $4.70 $4.32 $3.58 $3.35 $3.27 $2.97
2.75" $7.16 $5.50 $4.91 $4.16 $3.93 $3.83 $3.51
3.00" $7.92 $6.31 $5.49 $4.72 $4.49 $4.37 $4.05

Why Baseball Teams Love Trading Pins

Baseball trading pins have become essential at youth tournaments. When your team walks into Cooperstown Dreams Park or any major tournament, trading pins serve as your calling card—sparking conversations and friendships with teams from across the country.

Beyond the social aspect, custom pins commemorate your season. Players treasure them for years, displaying them on lanyards or in shadow boxes as tangible memories of their baseball journey. For coaches and parents, pins show team pride while staying on budget.

Where Teams Trade Pins

Cooperstown Dreams Park is the ultimate destination for pin trading, where teams from across the country gather for week-long tournaments. Little League World Series regional and state championships see heavy trading activity.

Travel ball teams participating in USSSA, Perfect Game, and Triple Crown circuits use pins to mark their journey. Many teams also create commemorative pins for championships, all-star selections, or special team milestones.

Choosing the Right Pin Size

For 8U-10U teams (Little League Minors): We recommend 1.25-1.5 inch pins. Perfect for younger players with simpler designs that don't require excessive detail.

For 11U-13U teams (Little League Majors): The 1.5 inch size is most popular. It's the sweet spot that provides space for team names, mascots, and player numbers while staying affordable when ordering 200-300 pins.

For 14U+ teams (High School, Babe Ruth): Teams often choose 1.75-2 inch pins for intricate designs and detailed mascots. Larger pins make a bigger statement but cost more per pin.

Frequently Asked Questions

What size baseball trading pins are most popular?

For youth baseball teams (ages 8-14), 1.5 inch pins are most popular as they provide enough detail while remaining affordable. Little League Minors (8U-10U) often choose 1.25-1.5 inch pins. Little League Majors and travel ball teams (11U-13U) prefer 1.5 inch pins for the perfect balance of detail and cost. High school and Babe Ruth teams (14U+) frequently select 1.75-2 inch pins for more intricate designs.

Can I add player names to baseball trading pins?

Yes! Many teams add individual player names, jersey numbers, or positions to their baseball trading pins. This is especially popular for travel teams and tournament commemorative pins where teams want to remember specific roster members. Custom text options typically add $0.25-$0.50 per pin depending on the amount of text and complexity.

How many trading pins should I order for Cooperstown?

Most teams order 200-300 pins for Cooperstown Dreams Park. Here's the breakdown: 200 pins work for smaller teams (10-12 players, giving each player about 15-18 pins for trading), 250 pins suit average-sized teams (12-14 players, about 18-20 pins per player), and 300 pins are ideal for larger teams or active traders (14+ players, 20-22 pins each). Remember, pins are meant for trading throughout the week-long tournament, not keeping.

What's the turnaround time for custom baseball pins?

Standard production time is 2-3 weeks from the time you approve your digital proof. We also offer rush service with 10-14 day turnaround for teams with upcoming tournaments. All orders include free shipping within the continental United States. We recommend ordering as early as possible, especially if you need pins between June 1 and July 31 (peak baseball season).

Are baseball trading pins suitable for Little League and travel ball?

Absolutely! Our baseball trading pins are perfect for all levels of youth baseball including Little League, Pony League, Babe Ruth, Cal Ripken, USSSA, and travel ball teams. We've worked with over 2,000 baseball teams and understand the specific needs of youth leagues, from Little League Minors all the way through high school baseball.

Order With Ease

Ordering your trading pins from us could not be easier! With our fast, friendly, fun process, you’ll have exactly the pins you want faster than you ever thought possible!

Submit Your Idea

Upload your logo or sketch

Get a Free Design Proof

Approve your design

We Produce Your Pins

Using quality materials

You Receive & Trade

Delivered for game day

Get Started Today

Already Know What You Want?

Great! Head on over to our free proof page , call us toll-free at +1 866-860-8842 , or email us at sales@tradingpinsdirect.com and one of our friendly, knowledgeable customer service representatives will be happy to prepare a no-obligation free quote for you!

Free Proof